Is paying a credit card annual fee worth it?

Advertiser disclosure: Content provided by www.redventures.com. Fox and its content partners earn compensation from the affiliate companies below. This content doesn’t include all available offers, and compensation may impact how and where links appear in the content.

Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more.

Many credit cards offer cash back and rewards without charging an annual fee. So when is paying a yearly expense worth it? 

The answer isn't as simple as you might think. Many cards with annual fees offer more robust rewards and perks that can make travel, shopping, and dining out less expensive. These enhanced bonuses may even outweigh the annual fee costs. 

Here are the pros and cons of paying a credit card annual fee, helping you determine whether it's worth it. 

Understanding credit card annual fees

A credit card's annual fee is the fixed amount you pay to maintain your account and access the card's features and benefits. Depending on the card issuer and the specific card, annual fees can range from around $50 to over $500.

Around 27% of cards issued by large banks have an annual fee, and 9.5% of cards issued by smaller institutions charge them, according to a report by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. The average annual fee was $157 for the largest issuers and $94 for smaller issuers.

Typically, cards with more extensive rewards, luxury perks, and premium benefits tend to have higher annual fees. Many basic credit cards designed for everyday use or credit building often have no annual fee.

Examples of credit cards with annual fees 

Credit cards with annual fees offer rewards and benefits that vary based on the issuer, card type, and annual fee amount. To understand the potential value you can receive at different price points, let's take a look at some popular credit cards with annual fees:

• Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card 
• Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card
• American Express® Gold Card
• Chase Sapphire Reserve®
• The Platinum Card® from American Express

Advantages of paying an annual fee

While paying a fee to use a credit card may seem counterintuitive, there are several advantages to choosing a card with an annual fee. 

• Enhanced rewards: Cards with annual fees often offer more generous rewards than their no-annual-fee counterparts. This can include higher earning rates, bonus categories, and more flexible redemption options.
• Valuable sign-up bonuses: Many premium cards with annual fees offer substantial sign-up bonuses to new cardholders who meet a minimum spending requirement within a specified timeframe. These bonuses can be worth hundreds of dollars in cash back, travel rewards, or other perks, often far exceeding the cost of the annual fee.
• Luxury travel benefits: High-end travel cards with annual fees often provide an array of perks designed to enhance your travel experience. This can include airport lounge access, travel credits, elite hotel status, concierge services, and more. For frequent travelers, these benefits can offer significant value and convenience.
• Exclusive discounts and experiences: Some cards with annual fees partner with retailers and event organizers to offer exclusive discounts. This includes preferred seating at concerts and sporting events and discounts on shopping, dining, and entertainment.
• Robust insurance protections: Many premium cards offer enhanced insurance coverage for purchases, travel, and other activities. This includes extended warranty protection, trip cancellation, interruption insurance, primary rental car coverage, and more. These benefits can offer peace of mind and potentially save you money if something unexpected were to happen.

Disadvantages of paying an annual fee

Despite the potential benefits, getting a credit card with an annual fee may also have some notable drawbacks. 

• Upfront cost: The most obvious disadvantage of a credit card annual fee is the upfront cost. Paying a significant fee each year can be a burden, especially if you're not taking full advantage of the card's rewards and benefits.
• Pressure to spend more: To justify the annual fee, you may feel pressure to spend more on your credit card than you otherwise would. This can lead to overspending and potentially carrying a balance, which can result in high interest charges and negate the value of any rewards earned.
• Complexity and restrictions: Cards with annual fees often have more complicated processes on how you earn and redeem rewards. For example, there may be blackout dates for travel or minimum redemption thresholds.
• Potential changes to benefits: Card issuers can change a card’s terms, rewards, and benefits at any time. This means that the perks you signed up for may be changed or eliminated, reducing the card's value and making the annual fee less worthwhile.

Factors to consider when deciding if an annual fee is worth it

When debating whether an annual fee card is worth it, it’s all about considering how well the rewards and perks match your spending habits. Doing a bit of upfront math can help you decide. 

"When determining whether to invest your money in anything, you should always examine the cost versus the value, and decide whether it’s worth it for you," says Patrick Yono, founder of Sure Life Financial. “Always remember that these are personal decisions, so what is valuable to others may not be valuable to you.”

Here are some factors to consider. 

Your spending habits and lifestyle 

Evaluate your spending patterns and see if they align with the card's rewards categories. Add up how much you spend in common categories like groceries, gas, and dining out and calculate how much you could stand to earn.

If you frequently spend in areas that earn bonus points or cash back, you'll be more likely to offset the annual fee with the rewards you accumulate. 
You’ll also want to consider whether the card's perks and benefits align with your lifestyle. For example, if you're a frequent traveler, a card with airport lounge access and travel credits may be more valuable to you than a cash back card with no travel perks.

Rewards and welcome bonus

Look closely at the card's rewards program and redemption options. Consider if the rewards are easy to earn and redeem and if they offer good value for your preferred redemption method (like travel, cash back, or gift cards).

Calculate the value of the card's sign-up bonus and determine if it alone can justify the annual fee for the first year. Keep in mind that sign-up bonuses are often a one-time benefit, so you'll need to review the card's ongoing value for subsequent years.

Added benefits

Annual fee cards often offer added perks to cardholders, many of them related to travel. Your card may give you a credit that covers the cost of signing up for TSA PreCheck or Global Entry. It might also offer lost luggage insurance or purchase protection. 

The Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card charges an annual fee of $95. But it offers trip cancellation/interruption insurance that reimburses cardholders up to $10,000 a person for prepaid, non-refundable travel expenses if their trips are canceled or cut short by sickness, severe weather or other covered reasons.  
Outside of just rewards earning potential, it’s important to consider these benefits and the value they might bring. If you travel regularly, perks like travel insurance and baggage insurance can make paying an annual fee worth it. 

When paying a credit card annual fee is worth it

Paying a credit card annual fee can be worth it in the following situations:

• You spend enough to offset the fee: If your monthly spending generates enough rewards to offset the annual fee, then the card may be a good choice. For example, if a card has a $95 annual fee and offers 2% cash back on all purchases, you'd need to spend at least $4,750 per year ($395 per month) to break even.
• You maximize the card's benefits: If you use the card's perks, such as airport lounge access or travel credits, the value can easily outweigh the annual fee. Frequent travelers and luxury shoppers often find that premium credit cards with annual fees offer significant value.
• The welcome bonus is substantial: Some credit cards offer sign-up bonuses that can be worth several hundred dollars or more. If the value of the bonus exceeds the annual fee (and you can meet the spending requirement responsibly), the card may be worth it for at least the first year.
• You pair the card with other rewards cards: If you pair a credit card with an annual fee with another rewards card, you can maximize your overall earning potential and justify the fee. For example, using a premium travel card for flights and hotels and a cash back card for everyday purchases can help you earn more rewards across the board.

When paying a credit card annual fee is not worth it

On the other hand, paying a credit card annual fee may not be worth it if:

• You don’t use the card enough: If your monthly spending is low or you only use the card occasionally, you may not generate enough rewards to offset the annual fee. In this case, a no-annual-fee card may be a better choice.
• The card’s rewards don’t align with your spending: If the card's rewards don't match your typical spending patterns, you may struggle to earn enough rewards to justify the fee. 
• You can’t afford the upfront cost: If the annual fee is a financial burden or you're concerned about adding another expense to your budget, it may be better to opt for a no-annual-fee card. 
• The benefits are redundant: If you already have other cards that offer similar perks and benefits, paying an additional annual fee for a new card may not provide extra value. 

Strategies for maximizing value from credit cards with annual fees 

If you decide that paying a credit card annual fee is worth it for you, consider the following strategies to maximize your value:

• Use the card for all eligible purchases: To accumulate rewards quickly, use your card for all purchases that earn bonus points or cash back. This can help you offset the annual fee and potentially earn a profit in rewards.
• Take advantage of all added benefits: Familiarize yourself with all the perks and benefits associated with your card, and make an effort to use them regularly. This can include airport lounge access, travel credits, statement credits, and more.
• Redeem rewards strategically: Choose redemption options that offer the highest value for your rewards. For example, redeeming travel rewards for flights or hotel stays often provides better value than redeeming for cash back or gift cards.
• Pair with complementary cards: Use your card alongside other rewards cards to maximize your earning potential across different spending categories. 
• Negotiate the annual fee: In some cases, you may be able to negotiate a reduced or waived annual fee with your card issuer. This is more likely if you have a long-standing relationship with the issuer and a history of responsible credit use. It never hurts to ask!

The bottom line 

Paying a credit card annual fee can be worth it if the rewards, perks, and benefits you receive outweigh the cost. However, it's essential to evaluate your spending habits and financial situation to determine if an annual fee makes sense for you.

By considering the card's rewards, sign-up bonus value, and added benefits, you can decide if a credit card with an annual fee is a good fit. And if you do choose to pay an annual fee, be sure to redeem rewards strategically to get the most value from your card.

Editorial disclosure: Opinions expressed are author's alone, not those of any bank, credit card issuer, or other entity. This content has not been reviewed, approved, or otherwise endorsed by any of the entities included in the post.